We bag our popcorn in thicker celophane bags and then we heat-seal them to keep in freshness.  These bags are approximately 14 inches tall x 4.5 inches wide and hold approximately 5 cups of product.  Our cheese flavors stay fresh approximately 8 weeks and the caramels and candied ones stay fresh around 3 months.  But most of the time it won't stay around that long!  All of our popcorn will stay fresher if you store it in a dry, cool area, away from heat and moisture.




Order Payment Notice

We apologize for any inconvenience, but at this time, we can only accept PayPal payments for any orders. We are experiencing an issue with our credit card vendor that we hope to address soon.  In the meantime, please utilize PayPal or you can always call our shop in Utica, IL and we will be happy to finalize your order and take your credit card info. The number to call is

815-691-8064. Thank you for your patience while we address this issue.

MasterCard Visa PayPal Discover
MasterCard, Visa, Paypal, Discover


Payment Options:
We accept Visa, Master Card, Discover and PAYPAL.


Shipping Policy:

All orders are created fresh in the order they are received. Most orders will ship within 2-4 business days.  During exceptionally busy times/holidays shipping time may be delayed to 1 week. If you are placing a gift order, please allow enough time for us to create and ship order to reach your recipient in time.


Shipping Rates:
Orders consisting of 2-4 items usually ship by USPS. Larger orders and tins ship by UPS.  Rates are determined by weight of product and size of order and are automatically figured in the shopping cart.


Return Policy:
Flutterby Gourmet Popcorn guarantees our product will reach you fresh and in good condition.  If for any reason you are unsatisfied with your order, please call us at 815-691-8064 for a store credit on your next order.


Cancellation Policy:
Once an order has been created and shipped, we are unable to cancel any orders. If you wish to cancel your order before it has been shipped, please call 815-691-8064 to cancel.


Privacy Policy: Flutterby Gourmet Popcorn will not share your personal information or email address with any third-party entities.




Classic Flavors   

Buttery Caramel

Caramel Apple         

Cheddar Pretzel Ale  

Cheesy Bacon              

Cheesy Cajun              

Cheesy Cheddar           Cheesy Jalapeno

Cheesy Pizza          

Chi-Town Combo    
Chivy Cheddar
Cincinnati Chili Cheese          
Dill White Cheddar     

Five Alarm Cheese      

Garlic Parmesan           

Kettle Korn                  

White Cheddar          

White Cheddar Ranch

Premium Flavors   

Bacon Chocolate Drizzle
Car w Pecans/Peanuts    

Choc Covered Cherries

(Milk & White)
Cornfetti (6 Fruity Flavors)
Cyclone (Cheese over Caramel)

Flaming Cyclone

Sea Salt Caramel

White Chocolate

Zebra Caramel (drizzled

with both chocolates)


Premium Plus Flavors

Banana Cream Pie
Birthday Cake
Caramel Surprise
Coyote Crunch (Caramel w Peanuts/Chocolate    
Heath Bar                        
Oreo Cookies & Cream
Peppermint Snow (seasonal)   P.B. Roos (Reeses)                    Turtles(Choc or White Choc)   White Chocolate w/ M&Ms    


723 S. Clark St. Utica, IL

Summer Hours:  

Mon/Wed 11am-5pm;

Closed Tues



 Sun 11am-5pm



PrintPrint | Sitemap
© Flutterby Gourmet Popcorn LLC